Nutter Butter Banana Pudding

I’m a freak. I’ll go ahead and admit it.  I love banana pudding. But…I hate bananas. I always pick the bananas out of my pudding.  To be honest, while I absolutely love this pudding that my good friend, Whitney, taught me how to make, I make my own little dish of banana-less pudding when I make this for a crowd of normal banana loving folks.  This stuff is off the chain, actually.  It’s awesome.  Why? Because it has NUTTER BUTTERS in it!!! And we all know that I love me some peanut butter! (See here and here for reference to my peanut butter obsession). Whitney made it for breakfast for Sunday School, which is perfectly acceptable in my book! It also works great to feed a crowd.  I like making it pretty in my trifle dish…especially on a hot summer day. You’re going to flip for this tasty banana pudding dish!

Nutter Butter Banana Pudding

Reach For:

3 small boxes of instant vanilla pudding
3 cups skim milk
8oz. light sour cream
1 large container of fat free whipped cream (Plus extra for topping)
1 package of Nutter Butters
3-4 bananas, sliced into small pieces

Mix pudding with milk and let sit in fridge for 5 minutes. Fold in sour cream and 2/3 of the whipped cream.Cut up bananas into small pieces and fold into pudding. Line the dish with cookies and then layer pudding and cookies until you reach the top of the dish.  Top with remaining whipped cream and sprinkle with crushed cookies.

Yields: 10-12 servings

Recipe Source: Whitney Smith

View Recipe Card | Print Friendly Version


See this recipe and many more yummy ones Featured on THE WEEKEND POTLUCK!

4 Comments on “Nutter Butter Banana Pudding”

  1. GREAT recipe! I grew up on Banana Pudding and it’s still a favorite. I don’t see how many bananas are used in the recipe though. I’m guessing 3 to 4? Doesn’t matter, I’m always improvising, but thought you might wanna know. Unless I’m just not seeing it, which is entirely possible! LOL…Thanks for posting this awesome recipe!


    1. Oh gracious me, Debbie! Thank you for catching that! With all my talk about how I hate bananas, but love banana pudding, I missed listing the most critical element for most people’s banana pudding…bananas LOL! Woopsie! Yes, you are right about 2-4 bananas (really as many as you like-depending on how small your slices are, but that’s the general amount I have used). I amended it on the site recipe and will fix the “fancy” recipe card soon. Thanks so much for stopping by. I hope you enjoy this recipe as much as I do! Please do stop by again! All the best and Christ’s richest blessings to you!

  2. Thanks, Emily! Just subscribed by email…I love finding great new blogs through the Weekend Potlucks. Especially since there are so many sweet Christian people out there writing them!

    1. I’m so glad to hear that, Deb! Feel free to spread the word to your friends. We are so excited to see what God does through this platform as we seek to Reach Beyond our Reach for His glory! Have a great day and keep cookin’ 🙂

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.